New York City's Most Unique Italian Restaurants Near Times Square

Are you a foodie looking for somewhere special to dine while visiting the Big Apple? If so, New York City’s Times Square has an excellent array of must-visit Italian restaurants during your stay. Whether you’re a food enthusiast or just looking for an incredible dining experience, you should explore Times Square’s dynamic restaurant scene!

From classic red sauce spots to contemporary gourmet experiences—there’s something delicious and unique for everyone. Get ready for some of the most unusual yet delicious creations here inspired by classic recipes around this iconic area. Come over to discover the taste sensations waiting to be discovered near Times Square!

 

Carmine’s

It’s impossible to have never heard of one of the most iconic Italian restaurants near Times Square, Carmine’s. Getting a table without booking in advance at Carmine’s is difficult. This family-style eatery serves classic Southern Italian dishes like Chicken Parmigiana. Try their world-famous Sunday Gravy!

Carmine’s unique is their “famiglia style” dishes – large entrees for sharing and perfect for a group. These dishes come in large pans or platters big enough to feed four hungry diners. With plenty of veggie options, you can get your fill! Carmine’s is perfect if you want to try real Italian American cuisine.

Tony’s Di Napoli

If you want something more traditional, visit Tony’s Di Napoli. Tony’s Di Napoli is an upscale Italian restaurant in Times Square. Their appetizers are the perfect start for a night of dining. Try the homemade mozzarella or Fried Calamari!

What makes Tony’s Di Napoli unique is their use of fresh, seasonal ingredients in all their dishes. Every dish has the freshest possible ingredients, ensuring every bite bursts with flavor. The experience is like dining in an Italian countryside villa without ever leaving Times Square.

Osteria al Doge

Osteria al Doge is an intimate Italian restaurant near Times Square. The restaurant specialises in Venetian-style cuisine and has been a local favorite for years. Osteria’s menu features traditional dishes from the Veneto region of Italy, such as pasta with fresh seafood and grilled meats.

This restaurant offers a unique culinary experience by transporting you to the Veneto region with its romantic atmosphere. Osteria al Doge is known for their excellent wine list and attentive service, making it perfect for an intimate dinner or special occasion. If you are looking for a Venetian getaway in the heart of Times Square, this is the place for you!

La Masseria

Another gem near Times Square is La Masseria, an Italian restaurant specializing in Pugliese cuisine. The menu features traditional dishes from the Apulia region of Italy, such as orecchiette pasta, fried seafood, and grilled meats.

Ancient fortified farmhouses inspire La Masseria Restaurant in the Puglia Region of Italy called “Masseria”. Fava beans, chickpeas, and lentils remain a core element in many of La Masseria’s entrees. The 250-bottle wine list encompasses all regions of Italy with a few of the best American and the rest of the world selections to complete the experience. This is a must-visit spot for foodies exploring traditional Italian cuisine in Times Square! the unique atmosphere, friendly service, and delicious cuisine will make your dining experience memorable.

Nino’s 46

If you want a gluten-free Italian dining experience, then Nino’s 46 is the perfect restaurant. The menu features a variety of gluten-free dishes that offer unique flavours and textures. Whether you are looking for traditional Italian favorites or something more exotic, Nino’s can accommodate your dietary needs without compromising taste.

Nino’s is casual and welcoming, making it a great spot for an evening out with friends. The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating options to enjoy your meal in the fresh air. Nino’s 46 is a delicious Italian dining experience in Times Square. Their gluten-free menu will make your visit unforgettable.

The Palm – Palm West

Once you’ve exhausted all the Italian spots near Times Square, The Palm – Palm West (also named The Palm West Side Restaurant) is great for classic Italian American steaks and seafood. This iconic restaurant offers a luxurious dining experience with its old-world charm and attentive service.

The menu features signature steaks, chops, and fresh seafood prepared with meticulous attention to detail. The Palm West Side also has an extensive wine list and delicious desserts to finish your meal. What is unique about this restaurant is that it still uses the original recipes from the first Palm restaurant in New York City. Whether looking for an intimate dinner or a special occasion meal, The Palm West Side will make your dining experience truly memorable.

The Best Italian Restaurant near Times Square With A Unique Menu: Sesamo!

The restaurants listed above are all great options for Italian cuisine in Times Square. Each has its unique atmosphere and menu, so you can find the perfect spot to satisfy your craving for Italian food. However, got the winner is: Sesamo Restaurant in Hell’s Kitchen.

Sesamo offers modern Italian cuisine with Asian influences. The first of its kind, the restaurant concept is rooted in their respect for Italian cuisine preparations and appreciation for Asian heritage and home cooking. Inspired by Itameshi (Japanese for “Italian”) cuisine, Sesamo expands on the concept and draws inspiration from many different regional influences in Asia. These influences create a unique menu that offers everything from Italian classics to creative Asian-Italian fusion dishes.

Sesamo is the perfect spot for a special night out in Times Square, but it’s also great for casual dining with friends. The restaurant’s cozy atmosphere and attentive staff make it an ideal spot to enjoy Italian food in Hell’s kitchen. Whether you are looking for classic Italian dishes or something new and innovative, Sesamo is the perfect spot to experience a unique Italian dining experience.

With so many options near Times Square, you will surely find the perfect Italian restaurant to suit your needs! The options are endless, from traditional favourites at La Masseria to modern Asian-Italian fusion dishes at Sesamo. Enjoy a unique Italian dining experience and make your visit to Times Square memorable with one of these amazing restaurants!